Carragher said: "The first goal was definitely offside. I was chasing Phillips and I could see Beattie was ahead of him when he passed or miscontrolled the ball to him. I was behind Beattie and I was the last man so he had to be offside.
"I can't believe the linesman didn't see it. It was an unbelievable sion. I always try to be very honest and to say we feel cheated might be going too far, but that could cost us a place in the Champions League."